Dependable Truck Forum

High mileage trucks and SUVs. Service records, what fails, and what people paid.

Home/Dependable trucks & SUVs/4Runner 4.0 vs Highlander 3.5

4Runner 4.0 or Highlander 3.5 for a 300k daily, which one actually gets there

fourrunner_forever High miler Grand Island, NE 31 posts · joined Nov 2025 2013 4Runner SR5 4.0 · 224k mi · owned 7 yr
#1

i already have a 2013 4Runner at 224,000, so the title is a little bit of a lie, but my daughter is driving now and we need a second one and i want it to be the last vehicle i buy for a decade. so the real question is which of these two ages better from here to 300,000, because i can get either one used in the 150k range for about the same money.

the 4Runner has the 1GR-FE 4.0, 236 horsepower, timing chain, body on frame, fifth gen since 2010 and barely changed since. mine has needed a water pump, a radiator and front struts and nothing else that was not a wear item. it also gets 17 miles a gallon on a good day and rides like the farm truck it basically is.

the Highlander has the 2GR 3.5, same family of engine more or less, unibody, and it will do 22 or 23 on the highway and the kids can actually hear each other in the back. the piece i am unsure about is whether a 150k Highlander nickels and dimes me on suspension and the AWD coupler in a way the 4Runner never has. tell me what you have seen at high miles on each, not the brochure version.

highlander_v6_owner Daily driver Mankato, MN 23 posts · joined Nov 2025 2014 Highlander XLE 3.5 AWD · 196k mi · owned 8 yr
#2

i am the obvious guy to answer half of this since i have a 2014 Highlander XLE 3.5 AWD at 196,000, bought it at 60k and i have put the rest on it myself in Minnesota winters.

the drivetrain has been close to boring, which is the compliment you want. 2GR-FKS in mine, the port and direct one, and it has had a water pump at 150k and that is the only thing off the engine. the AWD in these is not a locking system, it is a reactive coupler on the rear, and the only service it ever wanted was the rear differential fluid, which nobody at the dealer ever mentions. i do it at 60k intervals and it has been quiet.

where it costs you is the stuff that is not the engine. i have done struts all four corners, two wheel bearings, a pair of sway bar links that clunked, and the sliding second row rails get sticky with road salt. none of it is scary and all of it is a weekend. so the honest read is the Highlander will get to 300 but you will be doing chassis work the whole way, same as any 200,000 mile car.

three_hundred_k_club High miler Spartanburg, SC 48 posts · joined Nov 2025 2009 Tacoma 4.0 · 311k mi · owned 9 yr
#3

my handle is not a brag, it is a 2009 Tacoma 4.0 at 311,000, which is the little brother of your 4Runner engine, the 1GR, so i will speak for the orange side.

the 1GR is the one i would bet a 300,000 mile finish on without thinking hard. it is a timing chain, not a belt, so there is no 90,000 mile service bill with a water pump hiding behind it the way a belt motor has. the water pump on these does weep when it goes and it is driven off the chain, so you do it when you are in there for the chain tensioner if you ever are, and a lot of these never are. the known soft spots are the secondary air injection pumps on the early ones and that is more a 4Runner and Tundra thing than a Tacoma thing.

the trade is exactly what you said, you will average 17 and the Highlander will average 22, and over 150,000 more miles that fuel difference is real money, a couple thousand dollars a year is not nothing. if the miles are mostly highway and you want the quieter ride, the Highlander is the smarter buy. if you tow anything, ever, or you see gravel roads, the 4Runner is the one that will still be here. the full spec history on both is on Toyota's own site at toyota.com if you want to line up the model years.

timing_cover_done High miler Klamath Falls, OR 26 posts · joined Nov 2025 2010 Tundra 5.7 · 247k mi · owned 6 yr
#4

i run a 2010 Tundra 5.7 at 247,000 out here in Oregon so i am a V8 guy, but i grew up turning wrenches on the 4.0 and i will add the one failure nobody has said yet.

the 1GR-FE in the 2010 to about 2014 trucks had the secondary air injection system that throws a P2440 or P2442 and people quote you a thousand dollars for the pumps. there is a bypass and a known fix and it is not an engine problem, it is an emissions plumbing problem, but if you live in a county that does a tailpipe or OBD test it will hold up your tags until it is sorted. check the year, the later ones were better.

the Highlander 3.5 i have less hands on with, but the one thing i would check on a used one is whether anybody ever touched the water pump, because on the FKS motor it is buried and shops charge for the access. ask for a receipt. a 196,000 mile one that has never had the pump is living on time it does not have.

fourrunner_forever High miler Grand Island, NE 31 posts · joined Nov 2025 2013 4Runner SR5 4.0 · 224k mi · owned 7 yr
#5

this is the kind of answer i signed up for, thank you. the secondary air thing i had forgotten about and the example i am circling is a 2012, right in the window, so i will scan it myself before i part with a dime. the P2441 is apparently the usual code on these.

the fuel math is the part i keep coming back to. 17 against 22 over the next 150,000 miles is about 1,900 gallons of difference, and at Nebraska pump prices that is real. my wife drives most of the miles and she does not care that the 4Runner can climb a boat ramp, she cares that it is loud and thirsty.

so i think i have talked myself into the Highlander for her and i will keep flogging my own 4Runner until the frame gives up. which, out here where they salt the highways, might be the thing that ends it before the engine does. which is a whole other thread i am about to go start on the care board.

explorer_at_190k Daily driver Bristol, TN 14 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Explorer XLT 3.5 · 190k mi · owned 5 yr
#6

i am going to be the odd one out and say neither, only because i daily a 2016 Explorer 3.5 at 190,000 and i want people cross-shopping a three row to know what the domestic unibody costs to keep versus the Highlander.

the Explorer has been fine on the engine and expensive on everything Ford bolted around it, water pump is internal on the 3.5 Duratec and it is an engine-out job that runs two thousand dollars at a shop, which is the single scariest line item on the whole platform. the Highlander pump is a pain but it is not engine-out. that one difference would send me to the Toyota if i were buying again and planning to keep it to 300.

none of which helps you pick between your two, i know. i just did not want somebody reading this in two years, shopping a cheap Explorer against a Highlander, and not knowing about that water pump.

highlander_v6_owner Daily driver Mankato, MN 23 posts · joined Nov 2025 2014 Highlander XLE 3.5 AWD · 196k mi · owned 8 yr
#7

circling back because you said your wife will drive it. that pushes it hard toward the Highlander and here is the unglamorous reason. the heated seats, the power liftgate, the second row that slides so a kid can reach a dropped toy. at 196,000 all of that still works in mine and it is why it has never once come up as a vehicle we should replace.

buy the cleanest 2GR Highlander you can find with a water pump receipt in the folder, budget a thousand for struts and bearings in the first year, do the rear diff and the transfer fluid, and it will quietly do another hundred thousand. the 4Runner is the better truck and the worse daily, and you already own the truck.

Log in to reply. No account yet? ask a mod, it takes a day or two.

Also worth reading

Logbook tags

  • 4Runner 1GR
  • Highlander 2GR
  • body on frame
  • water pump
  • 300k