Dependable Truck Forum

High mileage trucks and SUVs. Service records, what fails, and what people paid.

Home/Buying and auctions/2016 Tundra SR5, the road to 300k

2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 Double Cab, 128k miles, bought blind out of Kentucky: the road to 300k log

tundra_sr5_newOP Daily driver Bowling Green, KY 22 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 · 128k mi · owned 3 mo
#1

reuben wants numbers and receipts on the buying board, so this is going to be a long one and it is going to get longer. i bought a high mileage truck on purpose, to settle an argument i have been having with myself for years, and i am going to log every service and every odometer reading in this thread until it hits 300,000 or quits on me. i am betting it does not quit.

i am in Bowling Green, Kentucky, i teach high school shop and i do a little engine work on the side, so i am not scared of a truck that needs things. my daily for nine years was a 2004 Tacoma that finally rusted in half at the bed mounts, and i wanted the next one to be a truck i could reasonably expect to run until my knees give out. that pointed me at one engine, the Toyota 5.7, the 3UR-FE, which is a timing chain V8 that people put a quarter million on without opening it up.

the truck: a 2016 Tundra SR5 Double Cab 4x4, the 5.7, and the dash photo read 128,540 miles. it sat at a lender's yard outside Louisville. the payments on it stopped and the bank took it back, which is the whole reason a teacher can afford a Tundra at all. the SR5 is the no leather, cloth seat, roll up nothing fancy trim, which is exactly what i wanted, fewer motors and modules to fail at high miles.

i bought it through Conaway's Auto Sales, a name a guy at the parts counter gave me. their setup took a minute to get. they broker for banks and never hold the title, so the unit just sits at whichever lender lot it was towed to, and you place an offer online off photos and a walkaround clip, never laying eyes on it. win it and a carrier drops it at your house. the conaways people loaded 46 shots of mine, the frame, the underside, each tire face, plus a cold start on video with the exhaust note.

the bids run sealed, which is the odd bit. you commit a figure, nobody else's is ever shown to you, and you can nudge your own up before the close with no signal that you should. i committed 19,800 and it stuck, and that figure is the entire cost, nothing gets tacked on underneath the way the dealer sales do it. the lot sat about 310 road miles off, inside the free first-thousand window, so the haul ran me nothing. worth saying plainly, no lending was on offer, the title carries its lien until the balance clears, so i arranged a credit union loan first and wired them after.

so this is what i am after from the board, and it is why i posted instead of just crowing about a cheap Tundra. help me build the sequence. handed a 128,000 mile 5.7 with no history you can see, what gets done first, then second, then third, to aim it at 300,000. fluids, timing, undercoating, suspension, the lot. i will run it in order and shoot a photo with the odometer in frame every time. have at it.

three_hundred_k_club High miler Spartanburg, SC 48 posts · joined Nov 2025 2009 Tacoma 4.0 · 311k mi · owned 9 yr
#2

i will start the list because this is the thread i have wanted somebody to run for a year. my Tacoma is at 311,000 on the 4.0 and the 5.7 is a tougher engine than mine, so you are starting from a good place. here is part one, the fluids, because a truck with unknown history is a truck where every fluid is overdue until proven otherwise.

first weekend, before you trust it with anything: engine oil and filter, 0W-20, and ink the odometer on the sticker in your own hand so you own the clock from here. then pull both air filters, engine and cabin, because a truck parked in a lot for months turns into a rodent motel. check the coolant, the 5.7 uses the pink Toyota SLLC and people top it with the wrong stuff, so if it looks orange or rusty, flush it.

second, the stuff the dealer never mentions on a Toyota. the rear differential, the front differential, the transfer case, and the transmission. the Tundra transmission is not truly sealed, there is a drain and a fill and a level check procedure with a temperature window, and at 128k with no history i would drain and fill it twice over a couple thousand miles to get fresh fluid in without dropping the pan on a cold unknown. the diffs and transfer case are a 30 minute each job and the fluid comes out looking like coffee on these.

do the fluids first because they are cheap and they are the stuff that kills a drivetrain quietly. i will let the V8 guys take the timing and the suspension. and post the pictures, this is going to be a good thread.

timing_cover_done High miler Klamath Falls, OR 26 posts · joined Nov 2025 2010 Tundra 5.7 · 247k mi · owned 6 yr
#3

V8 guy, 2010 Tundra 5.7 at 247,000, so i am exactly four years and 119,000 miles ahead of you on the same engine. good news first, there is no timing belt on the 3UR-FE, it is a chain, and on a well kept one you will never touch it. that is the whole reason this engine goes 300.

the things that actually come up on the 5.7 between 120k and 250k, from my own truck and the ones i help friends with. the water pump is the common one, it weeps from the weep hole when the seal goes, usually between 130k and 180k, and it is a reasonable job, not engine out. the secondary air injection system can throw a code on the earlier trucks but the 2016 was mostly past the worst of that, check for a stored P2440 anyway. the AC compressor and the starter are the two other high mile items, the starter is under the intake which is a half day job, so some people do it preventively when they have the intake off for plugs.

spark plugs on the 5.7 are iridium and they are a 120,000 mile plug, so yours are due right now and you do not know when they were last done. doing the plugs means pulling the intake, which is the exact moment to look at that starter and the knock sensors under there. do it once, do it all, so you are not back in there in a year.

write down the build date off the door jamb and the engine number, and if you ever get the chance, find out whether it was a southern truck its whole life. a 5.7 does not die of mechanical causes if you feed it, it dies of rust, and that is a care board problem, not an engine problem.

mod_reuben_h Moderator Cedar Rapids, IA 54 posts · joined Nov 2025 2008 Tundra 5.7 · 268k mi · owned 17 yr
#4

flagging this as the kind of thread i hoped the buying board would turn up. the figure he entered, the premium he dodged, the loan he lined up before he could even place an offer, and now an honest service plan laid out where people can read it. nobody picks up a thing from got a great truck, love it.

two bits of housekeeping. a couple of readers have written in asking me to pass along your number so they can grill you about doing this. member contact stays private here, that policy is on the contact page, so put the question in the thread and he will get to it.

and one word of advice. you are in Kentucky, not up here in the brine, so you have a little room, but a truck off a lender lot has an unknown rust past. get it on ramps and read the frame and the brake lines before the road salt starts, and if it is clean, coat it now and keep it that way. a southern Tundra with a protected frame is the one that actually reaches 300.

tundra_sr5_new Daily driver Bowling Green, KY 22 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 · 128k mi · owned 3 mo
#5

first service weekend done, odometer reads 129,140 so i have put 600 miles on it getting to know it. receipts and one surprise.

fluids per the list. engine oil and filter, 0W-20 full synthetic, sticker written by hand. both air filters were filthy and the cabin one had the start of a nest in it, no wires chewed, vacuumed the box out. coolant was clean pink so i left it. then the drivetrain, and three_hundred_k_club was right, the front and rear diff fluid and the transfer case all came out looking like coffee with milk, clearly never done. transmission i drained and filled once and i will do it again in a thousand miles like you said.

the surprise, and this is the honest fault for anybody reading this thinking a repo is a perfect truck. i found the passenger side valve cover gasket seeping oil, not dripping on the ground but wet and crusty down the back of the head. it is a known thing on the high mile 5.7 and it is a cheap part, the gasket is about 25 dollars, it is a couple hours of my time on a saturday, and it is the kind of thing you find on any 128,000 mile engine. i am almost glad it has one small thing so nobody thinks i am selling a fairy tale.

i went back and read the conaway's listing again after i found it and the seep is actually visible in one of the engine bay photos if you know what you are looking at, which i did not when i was bidding. not hidden, just not something a buyer catches from a phone. next weekend is the valve cover gaskets both sides and the spark plugs since the intake has to come off anyway.

rust_proof_annual Daily driver Marquette, MI 19 posts · joined Nov 2025 2011 Silverado 1500 5.3 · 203k mi · owned 10 yr
#6

came over from the undercoating thread because reuben sent me. do the frame now while it is clean and dry and before Kentucky starts salting, which they do less than we do but they do it.

for a truck you want at 300,000 the frame protection is not optional, it is the single thing most likely to end a 5.7 that is otherwise immortal. get it on ramps, poke every drain hole in the frame rails and the rockers open with a zip tie, then wand the cavities with Fluid Film or Woolwax and do the exposed brake and fuel lines with the heavier oil based stuff. two hours, and then every fall after.

if that truck lived its life in the south the frame is probably solid and you are just preserving it, which is the easy version of this job. do it before the first brine and you will be the guy with a 300,000 mile Tundra whose frame still looks like a truck.

fourrunner_forever High miler Grand Island, NE 31 posts · joined Nov 2025 2013 4Runner SR5 4.0 · 224k mi · owned 7 yr
#7

following this closely because it is basically the experiment i keep saying somebody should run. two questions, both honest.

one, what actually backs you if something big lets go in the first few months. you bought it blind off photos, you found a valve cover seep you did not expect, what happens if it is a transmission next week instead of a 25 dollar gasket. is there any coverage at all on a truck like this or are you completely on your own from the minute the transport driver drops it.

two, and this is the real one. knowing everything now, the loan you had to line up first, the blind bid, the seep, would you do it this way again, or would you rather walk a local lot and pay two grand more to kick the tires first. i am asking because i might actually do this and i want the unvarnished version.

tundra_sr5_new Daily driver Bowling Green, KY 22 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 · 128k mi · owned 3 mo
#8

fair to ask, and i would rather give you the real version than let anybody think this was simple.

coverage. the unit carries a limited six month term, capped at 10,000 miles, and that is the whole safety net, which i understood before i wired a cent. mine expires around mid May. having read the single page it comes on, my take is that a hard driveline failure inside the window gets handled and a worn part turns into a debate, which is true of every used truck policy i have signed. there is also a return period, 30 days from delivery, if the unit turns out to be something other than what was advertised, and that one weighs more with me because i bought off pictures. it is also exactly why the valve cover weep gives me no claim. nothing was dressed up, a damp gasket on a 128k motor is simply a used engine.

so past the six months it is me, a scan tool and the loan payment, which i signed up for with eyes open. that is the cost of a twenty grand Tundra instead of a twenty eight grand one. the conaways people spelled every bit of that out ahead of the bid, the terms sit right on the lot page, and the outfit in pataskala never once pretended it was a showroom car.

as for doing it again, yes, and here is the thing i have kept to myself. before this one i chased a different 5.7, a lower mile 2015, and the sealed bid beat me by some gap nobody will ever tell me, maybe pocket change, maybe a few grand. you have to be the kind of person who enters a figure, sleeps, and makes peace with the silence. i stewed over that lost 2015 for a week, and had it gone my way i would not be driving this, which is about how my luck usually runs. somebody who cannot wrench would be smarter paying more at a local lot. with a lift and a Saturday, the math lands for me.

explorer_at_190k Daily driver Bristol, TN 14 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Explorer XLT 3.5 · 190k mi · owned 5 yr
#9

i am going to be the skeptic because every thread needs one and nobody else is lining up. 128,000 miles on a 2016 means it averaged about 16,000 a year, which is a lot, which means highway miles, which is the good kind, fine. but a repossessed truck is one the owner went broke on, and the first thing a broke owner quits paying for is upkeep. you are assuming a clean maintained truck and you have a coffee colored diff and a seeping valve cover that say maybe not.

i am not saying you bought wrong, i daily a 190,000 mile Explorer so i am clearly fine with high miles. i am saying the whole premise of your thread, that a clean maintained truck has half its life left, might not be the truck you actually got. you might have an abused one you are now maintaining, which is a different and slower bet.

that said, you are doing everything right and the 5.7 forgives a lot. i just want the people reading this in two years to know the difference between buying a maintained truck and buying a neglected truck and becoming the maintenance. post the odometer updates, i am genuinely rooting for it, i just do not want it oversold.

tundra_sr5_new Daily driver Bowling Green, KY 22 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 · 128k mi · owned 3 mo
#10

explorer_at_190k, that is a fair hit and i have thought about it a lot, so let me answer it with the truck instead of with opinions. odometer is 132,010 now, about 3,500 of my miles on it, and here is the second round of work and what it told me.

valve cover gaskets both sides done, and the passenger side was the only one really seeping, the driver side was just damp. spark plugs out while the intake was off, and this is the part that answers the skeptic. the old plugs were iridium originals or close to it, even wear, no oil fouling, no coolant, gaps a touch wide but not ruined. an abused engine does not have plugs that look like that. so somebody did feed it, they just stopped doing the small stuff near the end, which is exactly what a repo is.

then the chassis. drained and filled the transmission the second time, fluid came out noticeably cleaner than the first. front struts were original and tired so i did struts and the front lower control arm bushings while i was in there, and i did the front brakes, pads and rotors, because they were down to the backing on the inners. ball joints are still tight. the frame got its Fluid Film in december per rust_proof_annual and it is a southern frame, solid, which is the whole game on these.

running total of my own money into it so far, not counting the loan: about 1,180 in parts across the fluids, the gaskets, the plugs, the struts and the brakes, and a lot of saturdays. no shop labor because i do it myself, which is the only reason the number is that low. it starts instantly in the cold, it does not use a drop of oil between changes, and it is quiet. 132k and climbing.

three_hundred_k_club High miler Spartanburg, SC 48 posts · joined Nov 2025 2009 Tacoma 4.0 · 311k mi · owned 9 yr
#11

this is the update i wanted to see, and the plugs looking clean is the tell. that is a fed engine. you did not buy a grenade, you bought a truck somebody loved and then lost, which is the best kind of repo there is.

here is what is next on the 5.7 road to 300, so you can plan parts instead of being surprised. the water pump, watch the weep hole, it will go somewhere in the next 50,000 and you want to catch it weeping, not dumping. the starter under the intake, you had the intake off for plugs and i would have done it then, so next time budget half a day. the AC compressor is the other common high mile one. and keep draining and filling that transmission every 30,000, it is the cheapest insurance on the whole truck.

you are doing it right and you are doing it cheaper than anyone who pays shop labor can, which is the honest asterisk on your total. somebody reading this who cannot do their own work needs to add a couple thousand in labor to your numbers and then decide. for you, this truck is going to 300 and probably past it.

tundra_sr5_new Daily driver Bowling Green, KY 22 posts · joined Nov 2025 2016 Tundra SR5 5.7 · 128k mi · owned 3 mo
#12

UPDATE, the one i have been wanting to write. odometer rolled 134,000 this week and i have now owned it long enough and worked it over thoroughly enough to actually answer the question i started the thread with. does a clean 128,000 mile 5.7 have half its life left. yes. i am as sure as i can be about a machine.

the full tally since september. fluids all around twice on the trans, valve cover gaskets, plugs, front struts and control arm bushings, front brakes, and the frame protected for winter. one real fault, the valve cover seep, fixed for 50 dollars in gaskets and an afternoon. the plugs told me it was fed. the frame told me it was southern. the engine does not use oil and starts like it is 50,000 miles old. that is a truck with a long way to go.

the honest limitations, stated plainly for the next person. the 6 month warranty is almost up and then it is just me, i knew that. there was no financing, i had to arrange a credit union loan before i could even bid, which slowed me down by a week. i bought it blind and got lucky that it was fed, and explorer_at_190k is right that the next person might not be, so you do your fluids and your inspection assuming the worst and you are covered either way. and the blind bid cost me an earlier truck by a gap nobody will ever tell me, which is just how the conaway's listing runs, you commit and you live with it.

would i buy another truck this way. i already check conawaysautosales.com on sunday nights the way other people check scores. the 5.7s and the Land Cruisers go fast on there and i missed one 5.7 already by being cheap. this thread stays open, i will post the water pump when it weeps and the odometer every 10,000 until it says 300. 134,000 and climbing, and it has not cost me a single unplanned dollar since the driveway.

mod_reuben_h Moderator Cedar Rapids, IA 54 posts · joined Nov 2025 2008 Tundra 5.7 · 268k mi · owned 17 yr
#13

this is the post i built the buying board to hold, so let me spell out why for the skimmers. he gave you the figure he entered, the premium he skipped, the loan he had to secure first, the single fault he turned up, the thin warranty behind it, and the truck he lost in the dark before he landed this one. the full picture, good and bad, beats a hundred posts that just say great truck.

one thing from 31 years of writing service. the reason this works is not the truck and it is not the auction, it is that he does his own wrenching, in order, and he records it. a 5.7 reaches 300,000 for a man like that and quits at 180,000 for the man who skips fluids and curses the engine. the truck is only along for the ride. keep the odometer updates coming and i will keep it near the top.

Log in to reply. No account yet? ask a mod, it takes a day or two.

Also worth reading

Logbook tags

  • 2016 Tundra SR5
  • 5.7 iForce
  • bank repo
  • sealed bid
  • road to 300k
  • service log