Dependable Truck Forum

High mileage trucks and SUVs. Service records, what fails, and what people paid.

Home/Maintenance, miles & reliability/Winter tires or all-terrains

Winter tires or just good all-terrains on a high-mileage 4x4, northern daily

highlander_v6_owner Daily driver Mankato, MN 23 posts · joined Nov 2025 2014 Highlander XLE 3.5 AWD · 196k mi · owned 8 yr
#1

Mankato, Minnesota, so i have thoughts, and i would rather lay the real cost out than cheerlead one way. my Highlander AWD at 196,000 rides on half worn all-seasons, and after our first real snow this week i slid clean through a stop i have made without thinking for years.

the question is not really AWD, AWD gets you moving and does nothing to stop you. the question is whether a dedicated set of winter tires on their own wheels is worth the money and the storage over just buying a good all-terrain and running it year round.

the dedicated set is four tires, four steel wheels, a TPMS decision and somewhere to keep the summer set. call it a thousand dollars the first year on a vehicle that is already worth maybe nine. that is the thing i am trying to decide is worth it or is just what people in Minnesota tell each other to do.

rust_proof_annual Daily driver Marquette, MI 19 posts · joined Nov 2025 2011 Silverado 1500 5.3 · 203k mi · owned 10 yr
#2

Marquette, so i am north of you and i will just tell you what the UP does, almost everybody who drives to work in winter runs a dedicated winter set. not because AWD does not work but because stopping and turning on ice is a tire problem and only a tire problem.

the thing that sold me years ago was a parking lot test a tire shop did, a studless winter tire against a half worn all season, both on the same truck, braking from 20 on packed snow. the winter tire stopped a full truck length shorter. a truck length is the difference between the intersection and somebody's bumper.

the storage and swap is the real cost, not the tires. i keep my summer set on wheels in the garage rafters and swap them myself in an afternoon, twice a year, and the winter tires last five or six seasons because they only run four months. spread over their life the dedicated set is cheaper per mile than you would guess, because neither set is wearing year round.

fourrunner_forever High miler Grand Island, NE 31 posts · joined Nov 2025 2013 4Runner SR5 4.0 · 224k mi · owned 7 yr
#3

Nebraska, so less snow than you two and more wind and ice. i run a good all-terrain year round on the 4Runner, a Wildpeak, and i will defend that choice for my use but not for yours.

the all-terrain with the mountain snowflake rating is a real winter tire by the rating, and it is great in snow depth, which is what i mostly fight, drifts across a county road. where it gives up ground to a dedicated winter tire is sheer ice, the studless ice compound stuff just grips glare ice better than any all-terrain can.

so the honest split is, if your winter is snow you can get away with a mountain snowflake all-terrain and skip the second set. if your winter is ice, and a Minnesota commute is ice, the dedicated winter tire is the right answer and i would not talk you out of it.

three_hundred_k_club High miler Spartanburg, SC 48 posts · joined Nov 2025 2009 Tacoma 4.0 · 311k mi · owned 9 yr
#4

South Carolina, i have no business in this thread, but i buy tires for a small lot so i will add the money angle nobody likes.

on a high mileage vehicle people talk themselves out of winter tires because the vehicle is only worth so much. that is backwards. the winter tires do not care what the truck is worth, they care what you and your family are worth, and that number did not go down because the odometer went up. the cheapest winter setup on steel wheels is a few hundred dollars and it is the best safety money you can spend on an old 4x4.

timing_cover_done High miler Klamath Falls, OR 26 posts · joined Nov 2025 2010 Tundra 5.7 · 247k mi · owned 6 yr
#5

Oregon, mountain passes, so my winter is chains law and freezing rain. dedicated winter tires here, no question, and i will add the heavy SUV wrinkle since this started on a Highlander.

a heavy vehicle takes longer to stop no matter what, momentum does not care about your tires, and that is the argument for the best winter tire you can buy on a heavy 4x4 rather than the cheapest. a loaded Tundra or a three row SUV on ice is a lot of weight to haul down and the tire is the only thing doing it. i buy the good ones and i replace them when the siping wears down, not when they are legally bald, because a worn winter tire is just an all season.

highlander_v6_owner Daily driver Mankato, MN 23 posts · joined Nov 2025 2014 Highlander XLE 3.5 AWD · 196k mi · owned 8 yr
#6

ordered the winter set, you talked me into it, specifically the parking lot truck-length story did it. a studless set on four steel wheels, i will swap them myself and keep the all seasons in the basement.

the thing that finally tipped me was the point that AWD gets me going and the tire stops me. i have been paying for AWD for eight years and treating the tires as an afterthought, which is exactly backwards for where i live. picked a well reviewed studless off michelin.com after reading the ratings. thanks all.

Log in to reply. No account yet? ask a mod, it takes a day or two.

Also worth reading

Logbook tags

  • winter tires
  • all-terrain
  • X-Ice
  • studless
  • second set of wheels